Detecting communities and densely connected groups may contribute to unravel the underlying relationships among the units present in diverse biological networks (e.g. interactomes, coexpression networks, ecological networks). We recently showed that communities can be precisely characterized by maximizing Surprise, a global network parameter. Here, we present SurpriseMe, a tool that integrates the outputs of seven of the best algorithms available to estimate the maximum Surprise value. SurpriseMe also generates distance matrices that allow visualizing the relationships among the solutions generated by the algorithms. We show that the communities present in small- and medium-sized networks, with up to 10 000 nodes, can be easily characterized: on standard PC computers, these analyses take less than an hour. Also, four of the algorithms may rapidly analyze networks with up to 100 000 nodes, given enough memory resources. Because of its performance and simplicity, SurpriseMe is a reference tool for community structure characterization.